Jordan Peterson, a Canadian psychologist, professor, and author, has garnered significant attention in the realm of self-help and motivational literature. His works, alongside other popular motivational books, focus on themes such as personal responsibility, meaning, and self-improvement. Peterson’s approach combines psychological insights, philosophical reflections, and mythological narratives to offer guidance on leading a disciplined and meaningful life.
Peterson’s most notable work, “12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos,” outlines twelve practical principles aimed at helping readers navigate life’s complexities. The book emphasises the importance of personal responsibility, discipline, and finding meaning. Each rule, such as “Stand up straight with your shoulders back” and “Treat yourself like someone you are responsible for helping,” offers a blend of practical advice and deep psychological insights. The follow-up, “Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life,” presents additional rules that focus on balancing order and chaos. In this book, Peterson explores how to cope with the uncertainties of modern life, encouraging readers to embrace creativity and be grateful despite suffering.
George Carlin tells us exactly what he thinks of the self help industrial cash machine
george carlin destroys jordan peterson's grift in 20 seconds pic.twitter.com/Y4zZZCHmd2
— ☀️👀 (@zei_squirrel) August 6, 2020
Critiquing self help books
Self-help books have become a pervasive element of contemporary culture, promising readers a pathway to personal development, success, and happiness. While these books can offer valuable insights and practical advice, they are also subject to significant critique. This essay will examine the criticisms of self-help literature, addressing issues such as oversimplification, commercialisation, and the potential for unrealistic expectations.
One of the primary criticisms of self-help books is their tendency to oversimplify complex issues. Many self-help authors distil intricate psychological, emotional, and social problems into a set of easy-to-follow steps or rules. While this simplification can make the advice more accessible, it often fails to acknowledge the nuanced nature of human experience. For instance, books like Jordan Peterson’s “12 Rules for Life” provide structured guidelines for living a more disciplined life. However, critics argue that such advice can be reductive, as it may not account for individual differences or the multifaceted nature of personal and societal challenges.
Another significant critique is the commercialisation of self-help literature. The self-help industry is a multi-billion-pound market, with authors, publishers, and marketers all capitalising on individuals’ desires for self-improvement. This commercial aspect can lead to the production of books that prioritise profitability over genuine value. Bestselling titles often rely on catchy titles, simplistic messages, and the promise of quick fixes, which can mislead readers into believing that profound personal change can be achieved effortlessly. This commercial approach can undermine the credibility of the advice offered, as it raises questions about the true motivations behind the authors’ work.
Self-help books also often promote the notion of individualism, which can be both empowering and problematic. On one hand, emphasising personal responsibility and self-reliance can encourage readers to take control of their lives and make positive changes. On the other hand, this focus on individualism can obscure the importance of social, economic, and structural factors that significantly influence one’s life circumstances. For example, while books like Stephen R. Covey’s “The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People” advocate for personal accountability, they may inadvertently ignore the systemic barriers that hinder many individuals from achieving their goals.
Furthermore, self-help literature can create unrealistic expectations. Many books in this genre are filled with success stories and anecdotes that portray transformation as an attainable goal for everyone. However, these narratives often gloss over the difficulties and setbacks that are an inherent part of the process. Readers may become disillusioned or feel inadequate when they fail to achieve the same results, leading to a sense of failure and frustration. This can be particularly damaging for individuals who are already struggling with self-esteem or mental health issues.
Despite these criticisms, it is important to acknowledge that self-help books can still offer genuine benefits. They can provide motivation, introduce new perspectives, and offer practical strategies for personal growth. Books like James Clear’s “Atomic Habits” provide readers with actionable advice on building positive habits and breaking negative ones, which can lead to meaningful improvements in their lives. However, it is crucial for readers to approach self-help literature with a critical mind, recognising its limitations and contextualising its advice within their own unique circumstances.
Therefore, while self-help books can serve as valuable resources for personal development, they have multiple flaws. The tendency to oversimplify complex issues, the commercial pressures driving their production, the emphasis on individualism, and the potential to create unrealistic expectations are all valid critiques that readers must consider. Ultimately, self-help books should be viewed as one of many tools available for personal growth, rather than as definitive solutions. By maintaining a critical perspective, readers can better navigate the vast landscape of self-help literature and extract the most useful insights for their individual journeys. However, this can incur great costs and tends to benefit only those who already have the resources. It is the resources that offer the opportunities to change one’s life much more than the self help gurus.
KEEP US ALIVE and join us in helping to bring reality and decency back by SUBSCRIBING to our Youtube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCQ1Ll1ylCg8U19AhNl-NoTg AND SUPPORTING US where you can: Award Winning Independent Citizen Media Needs Your Help. PLEASE SUPPORT US FOR JUST £2 A MONTH https://dorseteye.com/donate/
