HomeInternational NewsWAR WITH RUSSIA: 7 TALKING POINTS DEBUNKED

WAR WITH RUSSIA: 7 TALKING POINTS DEBUNKED

For four years the mainstream media has been awash with support for the Ukraine war. Now the case is also being made for the EU states and the UK entering into direct conflict with Russia. However, the arguments made by the proponents of war simply don’t stack up.

Let’s take a look.

1: Europe is under attack

Here’s a fact-check: It’s not.

One European country (Ukraine) is being attacked by another partly European country (Russia).

If Europe is to be treated as a single entity, then this could more accurately be described as a civil war in Eastern Europe. Alternatively, if we consider nations individually, then Russia is attacking only Ukraine and no other European country. In other words, Europe is not under attack.

Is Russia seeking to destabilise or manipulate Western Europe through social agitation and propaganda? Well, what of it? Aren’t our allies also doing this, both to ourselves and our opponents? The foreign influence of the United States and Israel among Western nations makes anything Russia can achieve pale into insignificance – yet we do not call for war with either of these two nations.

2: If Russia wins in Ukraine we’re next

This claim is questionable for several reasons:

a) Who exactly are “we”? The notion that Russia intends to attack the UK, France or Germany (the primary European funders of Ukraine’s war) is as speculative as the now infamous claim that Iraq possessed WMDs or the more recent claims that Iran was developing a nuclear bomb.

b) What does Russia “winning” in Ukraine actually mean? At present, subject to eventual negotiations, Russia appears likely to take 20% to 25% of Ukraine. Such a scenario fails to justify the hyperbole that “we’re next”.

c) At great military and economic cost Russia has spent four years capturing parts of Ukraine which were already favourable to Russian influence. Why would that imply “we’re next”? If Russia originally intended to seize the entire country, their campaign can already be considered a costly failure. Why would they pursue more war after such a reality check?

d) Given the immense military and economic costs, Russia was unable to control and continue its occupation of the European countries which were once part of the Soviet bloc. The Soviet bloc fell for good reason. So where is the evidence that Russia has the ability to repeat and then sustain such a conquest? The onus is on the proponents of war to provide such evidence.

Modern history shows that militarily occupying a country or territory against the will of its population is extremely challenging. Russia experienced this first-hand in Afghanistan and the former Soviet states, as well as observing it in numerous conflicts involving former colonial powers. The case for Russia aspiring to such conquest and being able to achieve and maintain it is implausible, to say the least.

3: The West should sustain Ukraine’s war so that Ukraine can get a better deal

However…

a) Ukraine is losing territory, its industry and infrastructure are being destroyed and it is being economically bankrupted by war. A negotiated settlement now would likely be more favourable and less damaging than a worse deal later. Ukraine’s decision to reject a more favourable deal in April 2022 than that currently offered by Russia only reinforces this point.

b) A deal now would prevent further Ukrainian suffering and death. Surely this immediate reality is more important than an entirely speculative and unlikely ‘better deal’?

4: Fighting should continue to preserve Ukraine’s sovereignty

If the EU/UK/US truly valued sovereignty, why are they not sending billions in military aid to groups resisting Israeli occupation in Syria, the West Bank, Lebanon or Gaza? Why are the EU and UK not resisting the United States’ kidnapping and assassination of foreign leaders and its political and economic interference in Cuba and South America? The selective application of sovereignty as a principle raises questions about the sincerity of this argument.

Is it possible the West’s perpetuation of the Ukraine war is more to do with domestic political advantage, the lobbying of the arms industry, a desire to weaken Russia and an interest in Ukrainian and Russian mineral wealth?

Further, respecting Ukraine’s sovereignty means respecting the majority wishes of Ukrainians – and a majority in Ukraine now want an end to the war even if it involves ceding territory (Gallup).

5: Russia shouldn’t gain from its aggression

This is true. Ideally, Russia should not benefit from invading another country. In a perfect world an overarching moral authority would:

  • Restore Ukraine’s 2014 borders;
  • Prevent further violence against ethnic Russians in the Donbas;
  • Ensure long-term peace and stability in the region.

However, reality presents serious obstacles:

a) The EU and UK do not possess a force great enough to achieve such an outcome and the United States is not willing, and may be unable, to provide such a force.

b) Any attempt by the US, the EU and UK to achieve this by direct military intervention would potentially cause more suffering for Ukrainians and undoubtedly cause immense suffering and death in both Western Europe and Russia. Would ideal moral objectives justify such a human cost?

c) The UK and EU, and certainly the United States, lack the moral authority to act as the world’s policeman. Their recent foreign interventions and their facilitation of on-going war crimes in Palestine, Syria, Iran and Lebanon, let alone their histories of colonialism, undermine any claims to moral superiority.

6: Russia BAD, US/UK/EU GOOD

While it is convenient to view Russia as the only villain of the piece, the reality is more complex. There is a long history of Western influence campaigns and militarisation in Eastern Europe, encouraging nationalism and anti-Russian sentiment. There is also considerable documentation of assurances given to Russia about limiting the eastward movement of NATO. More than this, NATO member states are morally compromised in other parts of the world, turning a blind eye to Israeli war crimes, genocide and occupation, backing extremist groups in various conflicts, invading and bombing nations whose governments they dislike.

A more accurate representation of today’s geopolitical landscape is: Russia BAD, US/UK/EU BAD… and any peace deal that reduces suffering GOOD.

Further, political trends in the UK and EU are shifting rightward. It is conceivable that within a decade many European nations may have far-right governments. Given this trajectory, is it wise to expand the military preparedness of individual European states?

7: The UK and the EU need to re-arm

The argument for re-armament fails to convince.

a) We are already armed. Both the UK and the EU possess nuclear deterrence.

b) Neither the UK nor the EU states ‘need to re-arm’ for defensive purposes. No one threatens us or seems likely to do so in the near or medium term.

c) The UK currently spends £60 billion a year on defence (£12,000 a minute on nuclear weapons alone). If this has not made us ‘defence capable’, then what has our money been paying for?

Conclusion

If our primary goal is to maximise the well-being of Ukrainians, then negotiating for peace is the clearest path forward. The argument that more warfare will eventually lead to a ‘better’ peace is speculative at best and disastrous at worst, as it entails more Ukrainian deaths for an uncertain future outcome.

To insist that Ukrainians should die for principles allegedly held by Western leaders and their supine media is a form of imperialist thinking that many Ukrainian soldiers deserting the battlefield might reasonably reject. This devastating war must come to an end sooner rather than later – and it is our moral duty as individuals and as governments to campaign for and work toward a negotiated peace.

As for direct war with Russia, to even contemplate this is a mark of grotesque indifference to mass human suffering and death.

With thanks to Cassowary Colorizations via Wikimedia Commons for the artillery image (public domain).

Luke Andreski

Luke Andreski is a founding member of the @EthicalRenewal and Ethical Intelligence collectives and author of Intelligent Ethics (2019) and Short Conversations: During The Plague (2020).

To report this post you need to login first.

DONATE

Dorset Eye Logo

DONATE

- Advertisment -

Most Popular