Former Shadow Cabinet member Chris Williamson exposes the propaganda being spread by the pro-Zionist Education Secretary, Bridget Phillipson, who is listed as a member of Labour Friends of Israel. She claims anti-Semitism is on the rise, and she’s earmarked £7m to tackle it. ‘But the figures are bogus, and she’s abusing her position to indoctrinate our kids.’
The pro-Zionist education secretary, @bphillipsonMP, who is listed as a member of @_LFI, claims anti-Semitism is on the rise, and she's earmarked £7m to tackle it. But the figures are bogus, and she's abusing her position to indoctrinate our kids. pic.twitter.com/UcEg4Nz97P
— Chris Williamson (@DerbyChrisW) October 12, 2024
The Labour Friends Of Israel Exposed
The issue of antisemitism within the Labour Party has been a persistent and deeply divisive topic in recent years. Much of the narrative has been shaped by groups such as the Labour Friends of Israel (LFI), who have played a significant role in the ongoing debate. Their influence and role in propagating a specific narrative surrounding antisemitism cannot be understated, yet this narrative often distorts the truth and serves wider political objectives that have little to do with genuine concerns about antisemitism.
The LFI, an organisation dedicated to promoting a close relationship between the British Labour Party and Israel, has been central in promoting claims that the Labour Party, particularly under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership, was riddled with antisemitism. These claims have been presented with a tone of moral urgency, suggesting that antisemitism had become systemic within the party. While it is crucial to acknowledge that antisemitism is a real and dangerous form of racism, the repeated claims by the LFI have often relied on exaggerated or outright false accusations, serving more as political manoeuvres than a genuine attempt to combat hatred.
The portrayal of Labour as institutionally antisemitic gained momentum after Corbyn became leader of the party in 2015. Corbyn, a long-standing critic of Israeli policy towards Palestinians, particularly its occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, became a lightning rod for accusations of antisemitism. His outspoken support for Palestinian rights and criticism of Israel’s human rights abuses were deliberately conflated with antisemitism by groups like the LFI. While it is essential to differentiate between legitimate criticism of the Israeli government and antisemitism, this distinction was blurred, often intentionally, in order to undermine Corbyn’s leadership and stifle pro-Palestinian voices within the party.
One of the most significant elements of this campaign of misinformation has been the weaponisation of antisemitism allegations for political ends. Accusations have been levelled not only at Corbyn but at a broad spectrum of the Labour left. These allegations, repeated with little evidence or context, have created a climate where criticism of Israel is swiftly labelled as antisemitic, regardless of whether any anti-Jewish sentiment is actually present. This strategy has been effective, with the media amplifying these claims and creating a widespread perception that Labour had a serious problem with antisemitism.
The reality is more nuanced. While there have undoubtedly been instances of antisemitism within the Labour Party, just as there are in wider society, the portrayal of the party as institutionally antisemitic has been grossly exaggerated. Internal Labour Party reports and investigations, such as the one led by the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), found that while there were issues to address, the scale of the problem was far smaller than the LFI and its allies suggested. Furthermore, many of the cases of alleged antisemitism were more complex than the media coverage implied, often involving disputes over the line between legitimate criticism of Israel and genuine antisemitism.
The LFI’s role in perpetuating this narrative cannot be divorced from its wider political goals. The organisation is committed to promoting a pro-Israel agenda within the Labour Party, and this has increasingly come into conflict with the rising support for Palestinian rights among Labour members, particularly under Corbyn’s leadership. By framing criticism of Israel as antisemitic, the LFI has sought to delegitimise and silence pro-Palestinian voices within the party. This tactic not only undermines the fight against real antisemitism but also stifles necessary debate about Israel’s actions and its ongoing occupation of Palestinian territories.
The media has played a central role in amplifying the LFI’s message, often failing to scrutinise the claims being made. Sensationalist headlines about antisemitism in Labour have frequently been based on flimsy or misleading evidence, contributing to a distorted picture of the situation. This has been compounded by the failure of many journalists to understand the nuances of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the difference between antisemitism and anti-Zionism. As a result, the media has often uncritically repeated the LFI’s narrative, reinforcing the perception that Labour was in crisis over antisemitism.
It is also important to recognise the broader political context in which these accusations have been made. Corbyn’s leadership represented a significant shift in British politics, with Labour moving towards a more left-wing, anti-austerity platform. This was deeply threatening to the political establishment, including many within Labour itself, who were uncomfortable with Corbyn’s socialist policies and his support for movements like Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS), which seeks to put economic pressure on Israel over its treatment of Palestinians. By weaponising antisemitism, the LFI and its allies within the Labour Party were able to undermine Corbyn’s leadership and derail his political agenda, ensuring that the party remained more aligned with centrist and pro-Israel policies.
The LFI’s repeated assertions about antisemitism within Labour also serve to distract from Israel’s actions in the occupied territories. By focusing attention on alleged antisemitism within the party, the LFI and its supporters have diverted attention away from the ongoing human rights abuses and mass murder being committed by the Israeli government. This is not to say that antisemitism should be ignored or downplayed, but the disproportionate focus on Labour’s supposed antisemitism crisis has come at the expense of a meaningful discussion about Israel’s policies and their impact on the Palestinian people.
In this context, the LFI’s campaign can be seen as part of a broader strategy to protect Israel from criticism, particularly from the left. By framing such criticism as antisemitic, the LFI and similar groups seek to shut down debate about Israel’s actions and delegitimise the growing movement in support of Palestinian rights. This strategy has been effective in the short term, but it comes with serious long-term consequences. It risks trivialising genuine antisemitism by using the term as a political weapon, and it undermines efforts to build solidarity with Palestinians and others struggling against oppression.
The lies and distortions propagated by the LFI have also had a damaging impact on the Labour Party itself. The constant accusations of antisemitism created a toxic atmosphere within the party, with members afraid to speak out for fear of being labelled antisemitic. This has silenced important voices and stifled debate, particularly on the issue of Palestine. It has also deepened divisions within the party, with the left and right increasingly at odds over how to address the issue. This infighting has weakened Labour as a political force, contributing to its defeat in the 2019 general election and leaving it struggling to present a united front in subsequent years.
The LFI’s actions have also had a broader impact on British politics. By contributing to the narrative that the left is inherently antisemitic, they have helped to delegitimise left-wing movements and ideas more generally. This has created a climate where progressive policies, particularly those related to foreign policy and international solidarity, are viewed with suspicion and hostility. It has also reinforced the idea that support for Palestinian rights is somehow incompatible with fighting racism, a notion that is both false and dangerous.
Therefore, the narrative promoted by the Labour Friends of Israel regarding antisemitism within the Labour Party is deeply misleading. While antisemitism is a serious issue that must be addressed wherever it arises, the LFI has consistently exaggerated and distorted the scale of the problem within Labour for political purposes. By conflating criticism of Israel with antisemitism, they have sought to silence pro-Palestinian voices and protect Israel from legitimate scrutiny. This campaign has been damaging not only to the Labour Party but to the broader fight against racism and for justice in Palestine. The LFI’s repeated propaganda about antisemitism is ultimately more about preserving the status quo in Israel-Palestine than it is about combating hatred against Jews, and it is vital that these lies are challenged.
Follow this Polish MP’s lead
"Don't you blackmail us with anti-semitism or the holocaust. Israel should be declared a terrorist state."
— Expat Vibes (@expatvibes) October 12, 2024
—🇵🇱 Poland's MEP Grzegorz Braun pic.twitter.com/GYqws6HvOl
KEEP US ALIVE and join us in helping to bring reality and decency back by SUBSCRIBING to our Youtube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCQ1Ll1ylCg8U19AhNl-NoTg AND SUPPORTING US where you can: Award Winning Independent Citizen Media Needs Your Help. PLEASE SUPPORT US FOR JUST £2 A MONTH https://dorseteye.com/donate/
