The Lie of the Land: Who Really Cares for the Countryside? – A Critical Analysis
Guy Shrubsole’s latest book, The Lie of the Land: Who Really Cares for the Countryside?, is a searing examination of the role that landownership plays in the degradation of Britain’s natural environment. Shrubsole argues that the myth of private landowners as responsible stewards of the countryside is fundamentally flawed and that an alternative model of common ownership and community-driven conservation is the key to reversing the ecological decline of Britain’s landscapes.
How Private Land Ownership is Destroying Nature
Private landownership in Britain is concentrated in the hands of a small elite, with half of England’s land owned by less than 1% of the population. Despite receiving over £9 billion in environmental stewardship grants in the past three decades, large landowners have presided over an alarming decline in biodiversity. Shrubsole highlights several key ways in which private ownership has contributed to environmental destruction:
1. Deforestation and Habitat Loss
Many large estates continue to clear forests and hedgerows for intensive agriculture, prioritising short-term profit over long-term ecological health. The destruction of ancient woodlands has led to severe habitat loss for countless species, pushing many to the brink of extinction.
2. Agricultural Intensification
Industrial farming practices, heavily subsidised by the government, have resulted in soil degradation, pesticide pollution, and the decline of farmland birds. Shrubsole notes that farmland bird populations have halved since 1970, a stark indicator of ecological imbalance.
3. Moorland Burning and River Pollution
Large estates in the uplands continue to burn moorland for grouse shooting, destroying peat bogs that serve as critical carbon sinks. At the same time, excessive fertiliser runoff from private agricultural estates has polluted rivers, leading to algal blooms and biodiversity collapse.
4. Exclusion of the Public from Nature
Privately owned land often restricts public access, preventing people from engaging with and caring for the countryside. Shrubsole argues that the disconnect between people and land perpetuates environmental neglect and alienation from nature.
The Case for Common Ownership
Shrubsole advocates for a shift towards common ownership and community-driven conservation, arguing that it offers a sustainable alternative to the current system of elite land control. He proposes several key solutions:
1. Community Land Trusts (CLTs)
CLTs allow local communities to collectively manage land for conservation, affordable housing, and sustainable agriculture. Successful examples in Scotland and Wales have demonstrated how community ownership can restore ecosystems while providing economic benefits.
2. Rewilding and Ecological Restoration
Community-led rewilding projects, such as the Knepp Estate and Trees for Life in Scotland, have shown how restoring natural processes can revive biodiversity. Shrubsole calls for government support to expand such initiatives on a national scale.
3. An Ecological Domesday Survey
A crucial policy proposal in The Lie of the Land is the introduction of an “ecological Domesday survey,” requiring large landowners to disclose the environmental impact of their estates every five years. Increased transparency would expose destructive practices and encourage better stewardship.
4. Expansion of the Right to Roam
Shrubsole argues for an expanded Right to Roam, granting greater public access to land while ensuring responsible environmental management. Greater public engagement with nature fosters a stronger collective responsibility for conservation.
Shrubsole’s Advocacy For Systemic Change
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/20fd3/20fd3b8730d72614a9fbb8bc5294d286f077c384" alt=""
The Lie of the Land is a vital contribution to the debate on landownership and environmental stewardship in Britain. Shrubsole’s meticulous research and passionate advocacy highlight the urgent need for systemic change. His call for common ownership and community-driven conservation provides a compelling vision for a future where the countryside is nurtured not by an elite few, but by the many who truly care for it.
As Britain faces escalating biodiversity loss and climate challenges, Shrubsole’s message is clear: only by reclaiming and reimagining land ownership can we hope to restore the natural world for future generations.