Justin Fashanu’s life remains one of the most poignant and complex tales in football history. His journey was marked by outstanding achievements and harrowing struggles as he navigated the intersecting oppressions of racism and homophobia in an era that offered little support for individuals like him. This following examines the life of Justin Fashanu, highlighting his triumphs on the field, the abuse he endured, and the complicated role played by his brother, John Fashanu.
Justinus Soni Fashanu was born on February 19, 1961, in Hackney, London, to a Nigerian father and a Guyanese mother. Alongside his younger brother John, Justin’s early years were fraught with hardship. Their parents separated when Justin was six, and shortly thereafter, the two brothers were placed in a Barnardo’s children’s home. Eventually, they were fostered by a white family in Norfolk, where they were among the few Black children in their community. This early experience of racial isolation and discrimination shaped Justin’s resilience and determination, traits that would later define his football career.
Justin’s talent for football was apparent from an early age. He joined Norwich City’s youth academy and quickly established himself as a gifted striker. In 1980, at just 19 years old, he scored what is widely regarded as one of the greatest goals in English football history—a spectacular volley against Liverpool that showcased his athleticism and technical prowess. The goal earned him the BBC Goal of the Season award and solidified his reputation as a rising star.
The following year, Justin made history by becoming the first Black footballer to command a £1 million transfer fee when he signed with Nottingham Forest. This groundbreaking achievement placed him in the spotlight, but it also brought immense pressure. At Forest, Justin struggled to adapt to the management style of Brian Clough, who was openly hostile toward him. Clough’s homophobia—evident in his derogatory remarks and refusal to understand Justin’s personal struggles—created an untenable working environment. Although Justin had not publicly come out as gay at the time, rumours about his sexuality circulated widely, exacerbating the challenges he faced.
Justin’s career began to falter after his stint at Nottingham Forest. He moved to several clubs, including Southampton, Notts County, and Brighton & Hove Albion, but he was unable to replicate the form that had once made him a household name. Amid these professional setbacks, Justin also grappled with deeply personal challenges. In 1990, he came out as gay in The Sun newspaper, making him the first professional footballer in the UK to do so. While this was a courageous and trailblazing act, the response from the football community and the public was overwhelmingly negative. Justin faced relentless homophobic abuse from fans, teammates, and the media. At a time when homosexuality was still heavily stigmatised in football and broader society, Justin’s openness made him a target for vitriol and exclusion.
The intersection of racism and homophobia compounded the abuse Justin endured. As a Black man in a predominantly white sport, he had already faced racial discrimination throughout his career. Fans often hurled racial slurs at him during matches, and he received little support from football authorities. Coming out as gay added another layer of marginalisation, isolating him further. The toxic masculinity pervasive in football culture at the time left little room for empathy or acceptance, and Justin’s bravery was met with hostility rather than admiration.
One of the most complex aspects of Justin’s story is his relationship with his younger brother, John Fashanu. Like Justin, John also became a professional footballer and enjoyed a successful career, notably with Wimbledon during their “Crazy Gang” era. However, the brothers’ relationship was strained, particularly after Justin’s public coming out. In an infamous interview, John referred to Justin as an “outcast” and later claimed he had offered him £75,000 to stay silent about his sexuality. While John’s comments were widely criticised, they reflected the societal attitudes of the time and the pressure he felt to distance himself from his brother to protect his own career.
John’s treatment of Justin has been a subject of significant debate and scrutiny. Some view it as a betrayal, while others interpret it as a symptom of the homophobia that permeated the football world and left John feeling compelled to conform to its prejudices. In later years, John expressed regret for his actions and acknowledged the pain he had caused his brother. However, their estrangement during Justin’s lifetime remains a tragic element of the story.
As Justin’s football career declined, he faced increasing financial difficulties and struggled with his mental health. He moved to the United States in the 1990s, hoping to revive his career and find acceptance. However, his time there was marred by controversy. In 1998, he was accused of sexually assaulting a 17-year-old male. Justin denied the allegations, claiming the encounter was consensual, but he faced the prospect of a trial and significant public scrutiny. Feeling overwhelmed and fearing an unjust outcome, Justin returned to London. On May 2, 1998, he tragically took his own life, leaving behind a note in which he maintained his innocence and lamented the lack of support he had received.
Justin’s death sent shockwaves through the football community and beyond. It highlighted the devastating consequences of systemic discrimination and the failure of institutions to support marginalised individuals. In the years since his passing, Justin’s legacy has been reassessed, and he is now celebrated as a pioneer who paved the way for greater acceptance of LGBTQ+ individuals in sport.
Organisations such as Stonewall and campaigns like Rainbow Laces have worked to challenge homophobia in football, drawing inspiration from Justin’s courage. Additionally, efforts to address racism in the sport have gained momentum, although significant challenges remain. Justin’s story serves as a stark reminder of the work still needed to create an inclusive environment where players can thrive regardless of their race or sexuality.
The role of John Fashanu in Justin’s life continues to be a topic of reflection. John’s actions and statements during Justin’s lifetime were undoubtedly hurtful, but they also underscore the pressures faced by individuals navigating a prejudiced industry. In the years since Justin’s death, John has spoken out against homophobia and racism, suggesting that his brother’s legacy has influenced his own understanding of these issues. While their relationship was fraught, it is clear that Justin’s bravery had a profound impact on those around him, even if that impact was not fully realised during his lifetime.
Justin Fashanu’s life was one of extraordinary highs and devastating lows. As the first Black footballer to command a £1 million transfer fee and the first openly gay professional footballer in the UK, he broke barriers that had long seemed insurmountable. Yet his achievements were overshadowed by the pervasive racism and homophobia of his time, which left him isolated and vulnerable. Justin’s story is a testament to his resilience and courage, as well as a sobering reminder of the cost of living authentically in a society that refuses to accept difference.
Today, Justin Fashanu is remembered not only for his remarkable talent on the football pitch but also for his pioneering spirit and the challenges he faced in the fight for acceptance. His life continues to inspire efforts to combat discrimination and create a more inclusive world, ensuring that his legacy endures as a beacon of hope and progress.
Also, in this article for The New Stateman in May 2012, Juliet Jacques discusses the effect that Justin Fashanu’s sexuality had on his career and his relationship with the media. It is a devastating indictment of attitudes that permeated in the 1970’s, 1980’s and 1990’s and led to his suicide by hanging in 1998. Some of those opposed to this bigotry formed The Justin Campaign: Campaigning Against Homophobia in Football. It seeks to demonstrate that homophobia is still hugely prevalent in both grassroots and professional football, challenge the stereotypes and misconceptions that exist around LGB & T (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual & Trans) people, and work towards a future where the visibility of LGB & T people in football is both accepted and celebrated.
If you have any experiences you would like to share relating to the topics discussed above, please submit.
