Summary of Horizon Scandal at UK Post Office

The Horizon scandal involved the UK Post Office and its Horizon IT system, which was responsible for managing financial transactions at post office branches. Between the early 2000s and 2010s, numerous postmasters and mistresses were accused of theft, fraud, and false accounting due to discrepancies in their branch accounts, all attributed to issues with the Horizon software. The Post Office relentlessly pursued legal action against these individuals, leading to bankruptcies, job losses, and even imprisonment for some.

However, it later emerged that the problems were largely due to flaws within the Horizon system, including software bugs and errors, which caused unexplained shortfalls in branch accounts. The Post Office initially denied these issues but eventually settled a group litigation brought by affected postmasters in 2019, acknowledging faults in the system and agreeing to compensate the wrongly accused. The scandal shed light on the imbalance of power between large organisations and individuals when it comes to technology-related disputes.

Now in 2024, in an election year, the Conservative Party is making a lot of noise. The reader should make up their own mind as to why this is.

A message from Chris Loder MP

‘I’ve today written to request that Paula Vennells CBE be referred to the Honours Forfeiture Committee. Ms Vennells served as CEO of the Post Office from 2012–19, a period in which problems with the infamous Horizon IT system were continually denied.

This institutional scandal has sickened me since I entered Parliament in 2019. I’ve spoken in Parliament on numerous occasions about this. While progress has been made, it needs to be quicker, and it’s about time the Metropolitan Police announced criminal proceedings.

I’ll stop at nothing until Ms Vennells’ CBE is removed, the appeals and recompense processes are removed from the Post Office, and victims are given proper justice.’

Remember, it is an election year, and as one person commented, ‘Blimey, he’s done something for once’.

*It needs to be pointed out that as suicide is no longer a criminal offence it is no longer ‘committed suicide’. The ‘committed’ was only relevant when the act of taking one’s life was illegal.


Paula Vennells, the former head of the Post Office, has promptly returned her CBE amidst the fallout from the Horizon IT scandal. This scandal resulted in the wrongful convictions of numerous sub-postmasters and mistresses. The issue gained widespread attention after the ITV drama, “Mr Bates vs The Post Office,” reignited interest in the controversy.

Between 1999 and 2015, over 700 Post Office branch managers faced convictions due to faults in the Horizon software, which inaccurately showed discrepancies in their store finances. Vennells expressed her commitment to cooperating with the ongoing inquiry and anticipates giving her testimony in the coming months.

Acknowledging the calls from affected sub-postmasters and others, Vennells publicly confirmed her immediate return of the CBE. She expressed profound regret for the anguish caused to those wrongfully accused and pledged to focus on aiding the inquiry without making further public statements until its conclusion.

The investigation, ongoing since 2020, is set to resume hearings, with individuals linked to the Post Office and Fujitsu—developer of the flawed Horizon software—scheduled for questioning in the upcoming weeks. The move by Vennells to return her CBE received support from government ministers and critics who deemed it an appropriate step to maintain the honor system’s integrity.

Reflecting on Vennells’ position, former Conservative MP Lord Arbuthnot asserted that while it was commendable for her to return the honour, he believed that she should not have accepted it initially, given the circumstances.

Vennells’ tenure at the Post Office began in 2007, culminating in her appointment as CEO in 2012. The company’s prosecution of sub-postmasters started in 2000, and during Vennells’ leadership, investigations into the Horizon system’s issues began, leading to a legal challenge against the Post Office in 2017.

Vennells faced mounting criticism and eventually resigned in 2019, coinciding with the reception of her CBE. Subsequently, when a judge overturned convictions of sub-postmasters and mistresses in 2019, she expressed deep regret for their suffering.

Beyond Vennells, others involved in the scandal faced scrutiny. Political figures like Sir Ed Davey and entities like Fujitsu were subject to criticism. Davey defended himself against resignation demands, highlighting the Post Office’s dissemination of what he termed a “conspiracy of lies.” Meanwhile, Fujitsu acknowledged the inquiry’s importance and apologized for contributing to the distress faced by postmasters, committing to support the investigation’s proceedings.

As the inquiry continues to unravel events spanning over two decades, including the roles of various stakeholders, Fujitsu refrained from further comment to uphold the inquiry’s integrity.

Join us in helping to bring reality and decency back by SUBSCRIBING to our Youtube channel: SUPPORTING US where you can: Award Winning Independent Citizen Media Needs Your Help. PLEASE SUPPORT US FOR JUST £2 A MONTH

To report this post you need to login first.
Previous articleWeymouth’s new festival tackles the climate emergency
Next articleMP reveals the reality of Bibby Stockholm
Dorset Eye
Dorset Eye is an independent not for profit news website built to empower all people to have a voice. To be sustainable Dorset Eye needs your support. Please help us to deliver independent citizen news... by clicking the link below and contributing. Your support means everything for the future of Dorset Eye. Thank you.